The pumpkins have rotted, the candy is gone, and our sanity may never recover. That can only mean one thing — it’s time for the annual Rum & Regret Halloween Horrorcast! 🎃
In Episode 170, Andy is joined by special guest Steve Polivka (Mr. Soup) as they look back at their annual 31 for 31 Horror Movie Challenge — 31 scary movies watched over 31 days of October!
From terrifying surprises and hidden horror gems to absolute cinematic disasters that should have stayed buried, Andy and Steve break down their month-long journey through horror. Which movies delivered the scares? Which ones were surprisingly good? And which ones made them seriously question their life choices?
Expect plenty of laughs, brutally honest reviews, questionable movie selections, and maybe a few disagreements as we celebrate another Halloween season filled with blood, guts, jump scares, and regret.
31 movies. 31 days. Two horror fans. And absolutely no lessons learned.
🥃 Grab a drink, turn down the lights, and join us for the Rum & Regret Annual Halloween Horrorcast!
Andy’s List
Oct 1 – Good Boy (Hulu)
Oct 2 – Drop (Peacock)
Bonus – SoulM8te (Hulu)
Oct 3 – Sick (Peacock)
Oct 4 – Evil Dead Burn (HBO Max)
Oct 5 – Bambi – The Reckoning (Peacock)
Oct 6 – Black Phone 2 (Netflix)
Oct 7 – Pinocchio Unstrung (Peacock)
OCt 8 – Strung (Peacock)
Oct 9 – Becky (Netflix)
Oct 10 – The Wrath of Becky (Netflix)
Bonus – Buzzkill (Tubi)
Oct 11 – Come True (AMC+)
Oct 12 – VHS Mixtape (Shudder)
Oct 13 – Ick (Amazon Prime)
Oct 14 – Traumatika (Amazon Prime)
Oct 15 – He’s Watching You (Amazon Prime)
Oct 16 – Pitfall (Amazon Prime)
Oct 17 – Scream 7 (Amazon Prime)
Oct 18 – The Summoning (Amazon Prime)
Oct 19 – Round the Decay (Amazon Prime)
Oct 20 – Slient Night Deadly Night (Amazon Prime)
Oct 21 – Blood & Rust (Amazon Prime)
Oct 22 – Silent Bite (Amazon Prime)
Oct 23 – Undertone (HBO)
Bonus – Clayface (Theater)
Oct 24 – The Cycle (Shudder/AMC+)
Bonus – Tradgey Girls (Peacock)
Bonus – My Dead Best Friend (Amazon Prime)
Oct 25 – The Slasher Nurse (Amazon Prime)
Oct 26 – Hokum (Hulu)
Oct 27 – The Whisper Man (Netflix)
Oct 28 – The Strangers, TS – Prey at Night, TS Chapter 2 (Netflix, HBO)
Oct 29 – Psycho Killer (Hulu)
Oct 30 – Dolly (Hulu)
Oct 31 – Lee Cronin’s The Mummy (HBO)
Nov 1 – Thanksgiving (HBO)
Steve’s List
Day 1: Hey Stop Stabbing Me! (2003)
Day 2: The Slayer (1982)
Day 3: The Lawnmower Man (1992)
Day 4: The Devil Rides Out (1968)
Day 5: Halloween Pussy Trap! Kill! Kill! (2017)
Day 6: The Dead Next Door (1989)
Day 7: Ravenous (1999)
Day 8: Arachnophobia (1990)
Day 9: Evil Toons (1992)
Day 10: Sharknado 2: The Second One (2015)
Day 11: Killer Rack (2015)
Day 12: Ahockalypse (2018)
Day 13: Freaked (1994)
Day 14: Shrieker (1999)
Day 15: The Control Group (2014)
Day 16: Beetlejuice Beetlejuice (2024)
Day 17: Lady, Stay Dead (1981)
Day 18: The Shining (1980)
Day 19: Christmas Apparition (2018)
Day 20: Longlegs (2024)
Day 21:Filthy McNastiest: Apocalypse Fuck (2005)
Day 22: Monkey Shines (1988)
Day 23: The Wraith (1986)
Day 24: Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974)
Day 25: Ginger Dead Man 3: Saturday Night Cleaver (2011)
Day 26: Cult of Chucky (2017)
Day 27: Phantasm V: Ravager (2016)
Day 28: America’s Deadliest Home Video (1993)
Day 29: Crackcoon (2024)
Day 30: Primate (2025)
Day 31: Shelby Oaks (2025)
